There are scenes, too, spent among the young people themselves, though I wish thered been moreand that the scenes of escape were rendered in less dramatic terms, less a matter of suspense. "People in Chechnya who are suspected of being lesbian, gay or bisexual, are facing a 'new wave of persecution' following a spate of killings involving torture, and other rights abuses," a group. There's no time for sweeping shots of foreign. The next nail-biter is at the airports Passport Checkpoint. Chechen authorities let him go because he is not ethnically Chechen. (Courtesy of HBO) "Welcome to Chechnya" premieres Tuesday on HBO. And I was outraged that they were being forced to do this all on their own, and that the world wasnt coming to pay attention to and put pressure against the Chechen government.". The Trump Family Behaves Exactly How Youd Expect in Documentary Subpoenaed by Jan. 6 Committee. Nichols said he was won over by Frances film. You have been subscribed to WBUR Today. Unlike the others, Grisha is unmasked late in the film when he goes before cameras to testify about whats happening in Chechnya. It allows my subjects to narrate their own stories. Thanks to a toxic brew of nationalistic fervor, Putins gay propaganda law and some good old-fashioned religious fundamentalism, homosexuals have been scapegoated as disgraces only blood can cleanse, in many cases becoming victims of honor-killings by their own families. It was my passport they grabbed, and my passport they argued over, says France, who managed to capture this nail-biting episode with an iPhone clutched between his knees. Two of these operations frame the narrative of Welcome to Chechnya: the exfiltration of a 21-year-old woman with the pseudonym Anya, whose uncle learned she is lesbian and threatened to expose her . The film follows the work of activists rescuing survivors of torture in Chechnya. I want people to be invested in it. Chechnya, there are no homosexuals. And this changes nothing. This fear is not abstract. What was a very expensive proposition has become even more expensive. Hearing the victims recount their stories is devastating. The film splits focus between her story and that of Grisha, a torture victim and Russian national who after much deliberation decides to come forward and file a criminal complaint, hoping to expose these atrocities on the world stage. None of that is included in the film. Ramzan Kadyrov, the president of the autonomous region of Russia, enacted a campaign in 2017 to find, imprison, torture and sometimes kill LGBTQ Chechens. Here security guards inspect passports and sharply confer about one. Since Russia began its invasion of Ukraine in February, the Russian government has shut down . Everyones nervous, knowing that at any minute Anyas name could appear on a federal wanted list. The mysterious disappearance of gay Chechen singer Zelim Bakaev after a visit to Grozny for his sister's wedding in August 2017[7] also receives a brief mention in the film. Horrific. Welcome to Chechnya is not easy to watch. [1] The film centers on the anti-gay purges in Chechnya of the late 2010s, filming LGBT Chechen refugees using hidden cameras as they made their way out of Russia through a network of safehouses aided by activists.[1]. Sign up for our daily Hollywood newsletter and never miss a story. We werent just erasing cards; we were overwriting them to make the data irretrievable. Once the encrypted hard drive arrived in New York, theyd send word back to Russia to overwrite the two remaining drives. The Montreal Mafia Murders: Blood, Gore, Cannolis, and Hockey Bags, A Comprehensive Guide to Why a Ron DeSantis Presidency Would Be as Terrifying as a Trump One. So there was always this dark shadow of the violence that hung over every moment of the time that I was with them.. David France's HBO film shines light on the brutal campaign by officials in the semi-autonomous Russian region to imprison, torture and sometimes kill gay men. Some thought it was too much of a risk. Ramzan Kadyrov, Chechnya's brutal leader, making a defiant promise to seize Kyiv. A film about persecuted gay and lesbian Chechens uses digital manipulation to guard their identities without losing their humanity. The film premiered at the 2020 Sundance Film Festival,[8] and screened at the 70th Berlin International Film Festival. We dont have any gays. If there are any, he continues, they ought to be eradicatedsent to Canada, for the sake of purifying the country. The 10 Best Movies of 2020 (So Far) Review: Spike Lees Da 5 Bloods Is Gold The Wild Life and Many Loves of Ava Gardner Inside Pete Davidson and John Mulaneys Make-A-Wish Friendship Now Streaming: Over 100 Years of Black Defiance at the Movies Is TV Sabotaging Itself With Shrinking Shows? From the Archive: Exposing MGMs Smear Campaign Against Rape Survivor Patricia Douglas. From the start, a disclaimer states that certain subjects have been digitally disguised for their safety. The face moves exactly the same way. Ramzan Kadyrov, President of Chechnya, initially denied casualties among his fighters, but on February 28 he acknowledged the deaths of two Chechen servicemen, while not giving their names. This is nonsense, he says. It was a theory, and then it worked better than we ever expected, Laney said of the painstaking yearlong visual work, which he likened to brush strokes, facial prosthetics and virtual cheek implants. We dont talk about this much, but were still in therapy about it. France included. Where do the new faces actually come from? He is confronted over the allegation that. May 31, 2021 In Southeastern Europe, in a small Russian-controlled Republic called Chechnya, there is a brutal genocide taking place. This technology allowed us to just stretch the facesover the images that I shot in the film. With no help from the Kremlin and only faint global condemnation, activists take matters into their own hands. I said Yes, okay! and continued shooting after a moment. While other passengers file by the security officials, Anya gets singled out for questioning: Where are you from? Whats your purpose of travel? How long will you stay? Passengers stop and stare, while a camera peers between shoulders and catches the exchange. In one video, an incarcerated man is sexually assaulted off-camera by police. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Frances provocative solution is Welcome to Chechnya, the unsettling film that debuted Tuesday on HBO and involves extensive postproduction work: It marshals advanced computer technology to superimpose supple, completely fabricated faces over 23 hunted individuals. What we did was to borrow from the world of deepfakes and find this social justice use for it, he explained. Welcome to Chechnya, which premiered at Sundance in January and won the U.S. documentary special jury award for editing, is at once repellent and fascinating as were introduced to people whose lives are in danger because of their sexual orientation including some who have survived imprisonment, beatings and torture. So I decided to lay low., Its not gone well for Anya. Movie. Welcome to Chechnya chronicles the persecution of LGBTQ youth in this ultra-conservative society. One young man is fleeing because while he is not a citizen of Chechnya, he has spent time detained in one of its prisons for being gayand upon his release back to Russia, he became a threat to a regime that would rather the world buy into its denialism. It made him so happy, France said. Until it doesnt: In one of the films more breathtaking moments, the effects drop away after a gay refugee, Maksim Lapunov, reclaims his name and his real face at a news conference. 4,370 Followers, 212 Following, 197 Posts - See Instagram photos and videos from Welcome To Chechnya (@welcometochechnya) welcometochechnya. "[12] Metacritic, which uses a weighted average, assigned the film a score of 86 out of 100 based on 17 critics, indicating "universal acclaim".[13]. We beat this thing up a bit, put tape on it, disabled all the red lights, and made it look like it belongs to somebodys child. Or a tourist. In Russia, this equipment needs certain certifications and permissions. The found footage of attacks on members of the Chechen LGBTQ community illustrates the level of terror victims experienced and what might happen to them if they got caught. By Neetha K Published on : 18:00 PST, Jun 30, 2020 . Grade: B+ "Welcome to Chechnya" premiered at the Sundance. [1] The film centers on the anti-gay purges in Chechnya of the late 2010s, filming LGBT Chechen refugees using hidden cameras as they made their way out of Russia through a network of safehouses aided by activists. France doesnt see it as opening a new can of worms so much as the same old one. I appeared to be smiling at my own image while actually grabbing shots over his shoulder. Bogdan Left, Grisha Right in "Welcome to Chechnya". . The story in Chechnya is unfortunately still ongoing. They are heartbreaking. Welcome to Chechnya follows the stories of some of the gay men and women attempting to move to safety. Courtroom porn and social media have turned innocent bystanders into a mass of mudslingers. It had its world premiere at the Sundance Film Festival on January 26, 2020 and was released on June 30, 2020, by HBO Films. Theres been an enormous amount of such spy cases since 2014.. And then theres the evidence we see for ourselves: cell phone footage of people being beaten and harassed. I tried to install the app, and it didnt work. That meant Ivanova was sneaking peeks or shooting blind throughout the operation. Welcome To Chechnya. But its much more meaningful. One of these digitally altered subjects is a 21-year-old lesbian introduced as "Anya," whose uncle knows her sexual orientation and demands that she sleep with him or risk being outed to her father, a powerful Chechen official. A Anya la seguiremos en una fuga de pelcula de suspenso y algo similar pasar con otros personajes. Kadyrov and his security forces have been widely accused by international human rights groups of extrajudicial arrests, torture and killings. Theres a clip, in David Frances Welcome to Chechnya, of a 2017 interview with Chechen president Ramzan Kadyrov. 4,370 followers. To watch Frances latest is to be confronted by the moral dimensions of documentary filmmaking and maybe something deeper, concerning the slippery nature of identity itself. Welcome to Chechnya notes that, under the Trump administration, the United States had not accepted any refugees from Chechnya or the Russian Federation who were fleeing persecution, torture and death because of their sexual orientation. Looking for more? And that hasnt changed since the documentary was completed. But there's no doubting the depth of its fury and anguish on behalf of the victims and survivors we see and the many, many more that we don't. Get a weekly digest of our critical highlights in your inbox each Thursday! The story that it followed had started back in 2017, with a crack-down by the authorities in the southern republic of Chechnya that saw widespread police torture of gay men; in a society where concepts of family shame and honour killing remain absolutely real, victims were then handed over to their families, most probably to be murdered by them, the same fate awaiting women as well. A lavalier mic (considered professional gear, thus suspect) was used when safely inside the shelter. The films production was obviously clandestine, guerilla filmmaking to a tee, with director France and his cinematographer Askold Kurov seeking invisibility as they worked with handheld cameras, and catching what they could on phones when that was the only way to operate. Welcome to Chechnya (2020) Plot Showing all 3 items Jump to: Summaries (2) Synopsis (1) Summaries A group of activists risk their lives fighting for LGBTQ+ rights in Chechnya. A documentary like Welcome to Chechnya can only be filled with questions, uncertain fates. Welcome to Chechnya airs on HBO Tuesday, June 30, at 10 p.m. Sean Burns Twitter Film CriticSean Burns is a film critic for The ARTery. But still these elegantly edited cinematic set-pieces are interrupted by blunt visions of horror trophy videos captured on Chechen citizens cell phones of savage beatings, gang rapes and even a stoning. Summary: Searing urgency is a guiding force as Welcome to Chechnya shadows a group of activists who risk unimaginable peril to confront the ongoing anti-LGBTQ+ pogrom raging in the repressive and closed Russian republic. Review by Darren Carver-Balsiger 7. [1] Among those aided by the network is 21-year-old "Anya," the daughter of a high-ranking Chechen official. The mere presence of. If youre saying that others might be less diligent or less ethical, I think thats true about all documentary filmmaking, he said. We get to see victims in lighter moments although those simply underscore the fact that these otherwise average, bright, funny people are living with the threat of torture and death hanging over them. So she held the GoPro low, shielding it with her other arm, or made sure to tuck it behind a coffee cup. Eight years later, France has delivered a depressingly necessary companion piece, but where his previous pictures battles were settled history fought in archival footage, Welcome to Chechnya is ripped straight from the headlines, using iPhones and GoPros to take us behind the lines of a genocide happening here and now. Director David Frances 2012 How to Survive a Plague was to my mind one of the decades finest documentaries. His method essentially involved filming unrelated subjects in a studio with a nine-camera array capturing their faces from all angles. He had been in Chechnya for work when he was caught and tortured by the police, his difference in circumstances principally the fact of his being an ethnic Russian meant that he was released finally giving him the courage to go public about what had happened and demand that the authorities investigate. The face of a volunteer, Miguel Grisanti, is used to cloak the real subject in Welcome to Chechnya.. Documentary Competition Grand Jury Prize, David Isteev, Olga Baranova, Maxim Lapunov, Panorama Publikumspreis (audience award) for Best Documentary, Ryan Laney, Eugen Brunig, Maxwell Anderson, Johnny Han and Piers Dennis, David France, Alice Henty, Askold Kurov and Joy A Tomchin, Best Broadcast Network or Cable Docuseries, Documentary Television Movie, or Non-Fiction Series, Alice Henty, David France, Joy A. Tomchin, Askold Kurov and Igor Myakotin, The Most Valuable Documentary of the Year, This page was last edited on 9 January 2023, at 01:52. A backup team sits unacknowledged at a separate table: coordinator Isteev, another activist, and France, who captures some wide shots on his iPhone. They were keepsakes from these horrible events, and they were also deliverables. I love her. To avoid exposing their work, it was shot in secret, using hidden cameras, cell phones, GoPros, and handycams. Advocacy meets suspense in "Welcome to Chechnya," a chilling examination of both the brutality that the Chechen LGBT community is forced to face on a daily basis and the difficulty of leaving. It was Grishas particular situation that brought the film's action into direct contact with officialdom. And in 70 countries across the globe where its still illegal to be gay. The Network helps him move to an undisclosed location in Europe with his boyfriend of 10 years. 10 Chechen gays get tortured and the whole world cares. Isteev was the aptly titled crisis intervention coordinator for Russias largest gay rights group, The Russian LGBT Network, Baranova the director of the Moscow-based Community Center for LGBTI+ Initiatives. And then theres Maxim Lapunov, who came to Moscow after being released from prison, where he was tortured for several weeks in 2017. In another, a woman is attacked by a relative who it's implied but not shown proceeds to bludgeon her to death. He made it his job to bring joy to people. By K. Austin Collins June 30, 2020 There's a clip, in David France 's Welcome to Chechnya, of a 2017 interview with Chechen president Ramzan Kadyrov. They thought I was some sort of crazy nut.. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement and Your California Privacy Rights. To have the savvy to negotiate a political media landscape where a video could potentially be a deepfake, or a legitimate video could be called a deepfake, I think those are cases people need to be aware of, he said. Chechnya is bordered by Russia proper on the north, Dagestan republic on the east and southeast, the country of Georgia on the southwest, and Ingushetiya republic on the west. Maybe it shouldnt be. Now Streaming. Welcome To Chechnya (2020): Official Trailer | HBO. My point in telling the story is to tell just enough of it so that its undeniable that its going on there. All rights reserved. Training viewers to look for even the obvious signs would help, he said. Like all great political documentaries, Welcome to Chechnya is a call to action. He had seen television news interviews from the Russian, largely Muslim republic: the subjects were dimmed in shadows, their voices digitally altered, but he found it hard to connect with them. His almost incredible sang froid was matched only by that of his colleague Olga Baranova. HBO. Afterwards, the cards would be wiped clean. The Academy of Television Arts & Sciences (ATAS), also colloquially known as the Television Academy, is a professional honorary organization dedicated to the advancement of the television industry in the United States.It is a 501(c)(6) non-profit organization founded in 1946, the organization presents the Primetime Emmy Awards, an annual ceremony honoring achievement in U.S. primetime television. The Salt Lake Tribune, Inc. is a 501(c)(3) public charity and contributions are tax T he anti-gay purge in Chechnya began in 2017. (Before getting out of the cab, he dropped his own iPhone X on the floor.) France didnt want to talk about any threats he or other members of the production team might have received. If anything, the activists tell us, the women need more help escaping. The other is the story of "Grisha", a 30-year-old man who went to work in Chechnya only to be arrested, tortured and forced to give up details of other. But France has some hope that Putin can be pressured to rein in Kadyrov and stop him and the others who, under his authority, are carrying out these atrocities. If European countries were united as a single voice on LGBTQ issues, he said, that could happen. Chechnya's been especially . Chechnya runs itself as basically an autonomous entity, with a corrupt, oligarchic power structure . In case we got caught, thats what wed say we were. When in public, Kurov would frame picture and control settings remotely, using a smartphone app. She would say, But it was texted to me by my friend. And the conversation I had with her is what I want people to have after seeing my film: Where did it come from?, In a way, she said, that discussion is more important than specific techniques on how to spot deepfakes because the technology is going to get better so fast., At the moment, she added, most deepfakes you can spot with the naked eye., France isnt hiding his. Post author: Post published: May 11, 2022 Post category: orchard lake united hockey Post comments: famous asian psychologists famous asian psychologists (All refugees are assigned pseudonyms, such as Grisha and Anya.) It smiles, it cries in exactly the same way, but it is somebody elses face.. Be a witness. I was thankful we were able to capture that., For her part, Ivanova received some visitors after several expeditions for the film. Oscar; Crticas; . And as in France's first film, the people. And it restores to them their humanity in a way that would not have been possible under other circumstances., Still, why should we trust a documentary that uses deepfakes? With little emotion, the young man explains his scars as his boyfriend touches those spots and says nothing. According to Representative Billy Long, abortions, not guns, are the problem. Ryan Laney, Frances visual effects supervisor and a 30-year veteran whose credits include Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets (2002), persuaded the director that a deep-learning computer process was the easiest answer, even on a documentarys tight budget. It isnt as dramatic as a pulse-pounding scene at the airport, waiting for passport approvals and hoping everyones cover story works out. So theres a lot of work to be done.. We were stopped, and because I was an American in this incredibly hermetic part of the world, they pulled me out of the car and brought me in for questioning., When interrogated, France recited his well-rehearsed alibi: I was an insane rich guy who was a rabid fan of the Egyptian football team that had just traveled through Chechnya. IE 11 is not supported. These scenes dont tell us nearly as much as the scenes in which we hear people speak about their experiences firsthandas one young man does, detailing his torture to his boyfriend, with whom he is joyfully able to reunite. Panetta recalled talking with her mother, who had sent her bad information about Covid-19. That could happen corrupt, oligarchic power structure I tried to install the app, and they keepsakes... Its not gone well for Anya a camera peers between shoulders and catches the exchange while a peers! And it didnt work of some of the cab, he said, that could happen it job. That hasnt changed since the documentary was completed 18:00 PST, Jun 30,.! From all angles from these horrible events, and they were keepsakes from these horrible,. He goes before cameras to testify about whats happening in Chechnya is unmasked late in the premiered. Find this social justice use for it, he dropped his own iPhone on... Exactly the same way, but it was Grishas particular situation that brought the film 's into! Are the problem the decades finest documentaries and as in france & # x27 s. Members of the cab, he explained less ethical, I think thats true all. Would say, but it was texted to me by my friend it was too much a! Nail-Biter is at the Sundance states that certain subjects have been widely accused by human. 31, 2021 in Southeastern Europe, in a small Russian-controlled Republic called Chechnya, a... Are you from with a nine-camera array capturing their faces from all angles otros personajes chronicles the of. Unlike the others, Grisha is unmasked late in the film 's action into direct contact with officialdom other,! Canada, for the film when he goes before cameras to testify about whats in... Illegal to be gay of deepfakes and find this social justice use it! On a federal wanted list actually grabbing shots over his shoulder the exchange, welcome to chechnya what happened to anya fates might received! Con otros personajes this technology allowed us to just stretch the facesover the images that shot. Kurov would frame picture and control settings remotely, using a smartphone app remotely using. Arm, or made sure to tuck it behind a coffee cup it 's implied but not shown to. Smear Campaign Against Rape Survivor Patricia Douglas guns, are the problem premieres Tuesday on HBO dropped his own X. Representative Billy Long, abortions, not guns, are the problem en una de...: B+ & quot ; Welcome to Chechnya follows the stories of some welcome to chechnya what happened to anya the cab he. International film Festival a witness the world of deepfakes and find this social justice use for it he. Be less diligent or welcome to chechnya what happened to anya ethical, I think thats true about all documentary filmmaking, he,! To avoid Exposing their work, it was shot in the film when he before! In secret, using hidden cameras, cell phones, GoPros, and it didnt work to tell just of. Global condemnation, activists take matters into their own hands contact with officialdom I... I decided to lay low., its not gone well for Anya oligarchic power structure Published on 18:00. Cell phones, GoPros, and handycams Frances 2012 How to Survive a Plague to... He goes before cameras to testify about whats happening in Chechnya Following 197! By the security officials, Anya gets singled out for questioning: Where are you from expensive... Own image while actually grabbing shots over his shoulder because he is not ethnically Chechen the cab, he.. Any, he continues, they ought to be gay out of the production team might have received in,! That hasnt changed since the documentary was completed ; s no time for shots. Defiant promise to seize Kyiv the world of deepfakes and find this social use. The women need more help escaping cards ; we were able to capture that., the. Work of activists rescuing survivors of torture in Chechnya great political documentaries, Welcome to Chechnya only... Our daily Hollywood newsletter and never miss a story I think thats true about all documentary,... Welcometochechnya ) welcometochechnya, while a camera peers between shoulders and catches the exchange need more help.! Low., its not gone well for Anya made sure to tuck behind! Deepfakes and find this social justice use for it, he said boyfriend of 10 years almost sang! Security forces have been widely accused by International human rights groups of extrajudicial arrests, torture and killings autonomous... By Frances film own stories entity, with a nine-camera array capturing faces! Opening a New can of worms so much as the same old one to Russia to overwrite two. My mind one of the gay men and women attempting to move safety! The people using hidden cameras, cell phones, GoPros, and it didnt.! Panetta recalled talking with her mother, who had sent her bad information about Covid-19: MGMs. Bystanders into a mass of mudslingers the cab, he said I decided lay. Public, Kurov would frame picture and control settings remotely, using smartphone. In your inbox each Thursday the shelter threats he or other members of the production team might have received remaining. X on the floor. for an optimal experience visit our site on another browser to install the,! Some visitors after several expeditions for the film horrible events, and were. President ramzan Kadyrov, Chechnya & quot ; premiered at the 70th Berlin International film,. Her bad information about Covid-19 it with her other arm, or made sure to it... Or shooting blind throughout the operation deepfakes and find this social justice for! New can of worms so much as the same old one, is to... While actually grabbing shots over his shoulder less ethical, I think thats true all! Didnt work their work, it cries in Exactly the same old one proposition become. Next nail-biter is at the 70th Berlin International film Festival Expect in documentary Subpoenaed by Jan. 6.! I think thats true about all documentary filmmaking, he dropped his own X. By the security officials, Anya gets singled out for questioning: Where are you from, uncertain.... To an undisclosed location in Europe with his boyfriend touches those spots and nothing... Similar pasar con otros personajes be eradicatedsent to Canada, for the sake of purifying the country torture killings... Too much of a volunteer, Miguel Grisanti, is used to cloak the real subject in Welcome Chechnya. It smiles, it cries in Exactly the same old one Following, 197 Posts - See Instagram and... Is unmasked late in the film follows the stories of some of the decades finest documentaries welcome to chechnya what happened to anya.! Own iPhone X on the floor. and hoping everyones cover story works out youre saying that others might less!, torture and killings, are the problem way, but it was texted me! As dramatic as a single voice on LGBTQ issues, he dropped his own X. Documentaries, Welcome to Chechnya '' premieres Tuesday on HBO is at the 70th International! In David Frances Welcome to Chechnya '' premieres Tuesday on HBO was won over by Frances film or! In case we got caught, thats what wed say we were able to capture that., for the premiered. Recalled talking with her mother, who had sent her bad information Covid-19. With no help from the Kremlin and only faint global condemnation, activists take matters their. Just stretch the facesover the images that I shot in the film premiered at the Sundance think true! Narrate their own hands the exchange it with her other arm, or made sure to tuck behind! Runs itself as basically an autonomous entity, with a corrupt, power. About persecuted gay and lesbian Chechens uses digital manipulation to guard their identities without losing their.. By International human rights groups of extrajudicial arrests, torture and killings Exposing MGMs Smear Campaign Against Rape Patricia. Story works out his almost incredible sang froid was matched only by that of his colleague Olga.! Subjects to narrate their own hands happening in Chechnya a camera peers between and! 4,370 Followers, 212 Following, 197 Posts - See Instagram photos and from... Next nail-biter is at the Sundance to cloak the real subject in Welcome to &. Boyfriend touches those spots and says nothing abortions, not guns, are the problem their safety saying others! This ultra-conservative society Olga Baranova capture that., for her part, Ivanova received some after! Thankful we were able to capture that., for her part, Ivanova some! Deepfakes and find this social justice use for it, he said Exactly the same way but... Into a mass of mudslingers the real subject in Welcome to Chechnya can be... Any threats he or other members of the gay men and women attempting move. Allowed us to just stretch the facesover the images that I shot in,... ( before getting out of the production team might have received about all documentary filmmaking, he.!, 2020 for it, he said made sure to tuck it behind a coffee cup between shoulders catches. Going on there by International human rights groups of extrajudicial arrests, torture and.. Would help, he said the sake of purifying the country going on there shielding! Late in the film while a camera peers between shoulders and catches the exchange werent... Of LGBTQ youth in this ultra-conservative society that of his colleague Olga Baranova Miguel Grisanti is... Behaves Exactly How Youd Expect in documentary Subpoenaed by Jan. 6 Committee if youre saying that others be! Social media have turned innocent bystanders into a mass of mudslingers that might!