Is decoding an appropriate focus for students in mid-primary school and beyond? The impact on students of such careful explication of the code can be described as inoculative against reading failure. (2005). Are there any brochures or other printed materials that I can have? Dyslexia creates problems in reading where dysgraphia, also known as written expression disorder, creates problems in writing. Did the Corrective Reading program effects generalise to spelling? Prior, M., Sanson, A. Developmental Psychology, 30, 805-822. Acquire general recommendations for the classroom that enrich learning for beginning readers and writers. Because while students with dyslexia benefit from what my professor called good teaching, they are also likely to need additional support. Since reading can be such an exhausting struggle for them, they may focus almost entirely on decoding the words they are reading, and hardly notice the information that those words are providing. EducationNews.Org. It is an acquired ability that requires effort and incremental skill development. Accessed April 6, 2022. It is known that phonological process acuity is a strong predictor of reading success. Neuroimaging sheds new light on the phonological deficit in dyslexia. 279-332. allows for more accurate conversion to spellings of the sounds in words. Johnston, T., & Kirby, J. Cognitive processes in early reading development: accommodating individual differences into a model of acquisition. Phases of development in learning to read word by sight. The Picture Naming Test. (1972). It may be fruitful to supplement such analyses of group differences with analyses of outcomes for individual learners to enable a teasing apart of learner-by-treatment effect (Calhoon, Scarborough, & Miller, 2013, p.490). Learning and Instruction, 29, 6577. Boosting reading skills by direct instruction. June 6, 2022. Licensed Davis providers have successfully worked with many individuals over age 70. They are the emphasis on decoding skills (phonics) and the Direct Instruction approach to teaching the phonics content. Results for Word Attack were analysed using a single-factor between-subject analysis of covariance (ancova), with transformed pretest scores serving as the covariate and transformed posttest scores as the dependent variable. (1994). Lyon, G. R., & Moats, L.C. Issues of selection may jeopardise group comparability. (1998). Ramus, F. (2014). Reading comprehension and numeracy among junior secondary school students in Australia. Boston: Houghton-Mifflin. Torgesen, J., Wagner, R. K., Rashotte, C., Alexander, A., & Conway, T. (1997). Figure 5. You can take these steps: Success in employment can be difficult for adults who have dyslexia. Please let me know if Corrective reading will benefit him. SES differences in language processing skill and vocabulary are evident at 18 months. Lots of kids dread math. The emphasis on teaching quality rather than learner quality makes redundant any explanations of failure based on intelligence, race, readiness, first language, or home background. Singh, N.N., Deitz, D.E.D., & Singh, J. Engelmann, S., Becker, W. C., Carnine, D., & Gersten, R. (1988). https://dyslexiaida.org/adolescents-and-adults-with-dyslexia/. Reid Lyon, the primary architect of Reading First, was critical of the modification of his plan that funding should be provided only for programs with proven effectiveness to the easier-to-meet criterion that programs had only to be based on scientifically based reading research (Shaughnessy, 2007). The program has a systematic, explicit phonics emphasis, with attention to letter-sound correspondences, and to the phonemic awareness skills of segmenting and blending. Reading and Writing, 27(1), 5578. Here's some information to help you prepare for your appointment: Feel free to ask other questions during your appointment. Applied Psycholinguistics, 12, 91-121. Engelmann is thus critical of merely research-based programs, that is, programs constructed only to ensure each respected component is somewhere represented in the mix. Test of Phonological Awareness: Examiners Manual. Review of Comprehensive Programs. Reports of Operation Follow Through (Engelmann, Becker, Carnine, & Gersten, 1988; Grossen, 1996), and the studies reported in meta-analyses by White (1988) and by Adams and Engelmann (1996) have not been accorded the attention that might have been expected. Its hardly a revelation to argue that the adoption of evidence-based practice (EBP) in some other professions is far advanced in comparison to its use in education. Regular data-based monitoring may or may not occur. Effects of a short-term auxiliary reading program on the reading skills of incarcerated youth. There must be systematic, regular, and frequent teaching of phonological awareness, phonics and spelling (Department for Education and Employment, 1998, p.11). Calhoon, M. B., & Prescher, Y. There's no known way to correct the underlying brain differences that cause dyslexia. A correct response precludes the possibility of having used other than a phonological recoding strategy, or reading by analogy with similar real words. Al Otaiba argued that this group should be seen to comprise the truly learning disabled, as opposed to those Lyon (2003) described as instructional casualties. Statistical power analysis for the behavioural sciences (2nd ed.). A. R., Soden-Hensler, B., Kershaw, S., Taylor, J., & Schatschneider, C. (2013). The nature of phonological processing and its causal role in the acquisition of reading skills. Retrieved from http://www.nationalreadingpanel.org. New York: American Psychological Association, Division of Clinical Psychologists (Division 12). The health care provider is likely to ask you a number of questions, such as: Be ready to answer questions to make the most of your appointment time. In many cases, treatment can help children become competent readers. Australia: DEST. Torgesen, J.K. (2000). Bringing school records is especially helpful for the evaluation done by health care providers. Such a cohort suggests difficulties in evoking reading progress: the gap in proficiency rates between low-income and higher-income children widened by nearly 20 percent over the past decade and got worse in nearly every state. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 36(4), 285-293. Retrieved from http://www.eduweb.vic.gov.au/edulibrary/public/curricman/middleyear/research/successfulinterventions.doc. Franklin Spellers or similar handheld devices that assist in the spelling of words are also helpful, particularly when students are not using a computer to write. Dyslexia is a learning disorder that involves difficulty reading due to problems identifying speech sounds and learning how they relate to letters and words (decoding). (2004). Sackett, D., McRosenberg, W., Muir Gray, J. Contrary to the commonly-held belief that learning to read is natural and easy, learning to read is a complex linguistic achievement. (1993). Mayo Clinic is a not-for-profit organization. Reading programs that work: A review of programs for pre-kindergarten to 4th grade. Any effects on students of the test or testing procedure should have been equally distributed across both groups. Retrieved from http://www.fcrr.org/FCRRReports/PDF/corrective_reading_final.pdf, Snow, C. E., Burns, S., & Griffin, P. (Eds). Curriculum Review Panel. But a child can learn skills that improve reading and develop strategies to improve school performance and quality of life. Retrieved from http://cebm.jr2.ox.ac.uk/ebmisisnt.html#coredef. Early reports (Office of Management and Budget, 2007) indicated that it had a positive impact nationally; however, a criticism of it is that the criterion for acceptability of the programs used was diluted. (2007). Statistical Package for the Social Sciences [Computer Software]. Have ideas to use when teaching children with visual deficits. The Corrective Reading program has been evaluated on many occasions, though its effects on phonological processes have not previously been a focus. This has occurred among young practitioners because their training has emphasized the centrality of evidence in competent practice. IDA and WWC encourage us to focus on two critical elements: Teachers arent prepared to teach all young readers. Retrieved from. The schools like the support and they are seeing the results, The teachers have gained so much knowledge behind the data tracking. The outcomes of the study indicate that these skills can be developed, even in students who have had prior opportunity, but have been unable to do so in the context of earlier instruction. Perfetti, Beck, Bell, and Hughes (1987) noted that when structured code emphasis teaching was not provided, then initial levels of variables such as naming speed were predictive of reading progress. Psychological Science, 16(2), 234-238. (1997). Many start with an enthusiastic staff member, but fall away when the initiator leaves, loses interest, or the staff adopt a different priority emphasis. Barton is a marathon, not a race. , DC: Center for Research on the Education of Students Placed At Risk (CRESPAR), U.S. Department of Education. A number of factors are considered, such as: There's no known way to correct the underlying brain differences that cause dyslexia. These school qualities may be efficacious in enhancing reading development but not obvious until the programs commencement, and the subsequent student progress falsely attributed to program effect. In summary, Corrective Reading programs instructional content and design is considered to meet the criteria for acceptance as a scientifically based reading program (Oregon Reading First, 2004). They concisely lay out what effective reading instruction for students with dyslexia looks like. Retrieved from http://www.edreform.com/pubs/bestbets.pdf. "Mayo," "Mayo Clinic," "MayoClinic.org," "Mayo Clinic Healthy Living," and the triple-shield Mayo Clinic logo are trademarks of Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and Research. 2020; doi:10.1542/peds.2019-3046. Jencks, C. S., Smith, M., Acland, H., Bane, M. J., Cohen, D., Ginits, H., et al. It was rigorous and professional, but sensitive to the individual., Schools with NIFDI have more and better discussions about how what they are doing is impacting individual student achievement.. Intervention for these students is more difficult, but significant gains are achievable, and older students should not be ignored simply because early intervention is easier to implement and promote. Those of us who can, need to be pulling on those more systemic teacher preparation levers. School Psychology Review, 23, 372-391. Response to varying amounts of time in reading intervention for students with low response to intervention. Primary framework for literacy and mathematics. Interaction (+ SE) between experimental and control group at pre- and posttest for Word Attack. Grossen, B. the STAAR math or reading assessment. Retrieved from http://www.standards.dfes.gov.uk/primaryframeworks/. In their discussion of a best practice, they also note something worth reading twice: This approach not only helps students with dyslexia, but there is substantial evidence that it is more effective for all readers., Two critical elements of effective reading instruction. Rosenshine, B. Melbourne: Australian Council for Educational Research. Reading First: Hard to live withor without. The pretests and posttests for both groups were seven months apart. Smith, S. A. It offers three principles that benefit students with dyslexia: instruction should be systematic, explicit, and diagnostic. Grossen reported that students in the Corrective Reading interventions progressed faster than students in the comparison groups in all but one of the studies. Construct: Phonological Recoding in Lexical Access (or Rapid Automatised Naming RAN). (2001). Points for this passage are earned if the student reads it within a specified rate and error criterion. The test comprised 60 pictures in 3 pages, and students were allowed one minute to name as many as they could. For example, the American Federation of Teachers series of documents Building On The Best, Learning From What Works (1997) nominates Direct Instruction programs among each of its recommendations across different facets of education: Seven Promising Reading and English Language Arts Programs, Three Promising High School Remedial Reading Programs, Five Promising Remedial Reading Intervention Program and, Six Promising Schoolwide Reform Programs. Children who don't get help until later grades may have more difficulty learning the skills needed to read well. Grossen B. (1990). It is possible to analyse the content of these programs, and then assume incorrectly that the mere presence of those characteristics is sufficient to ensure effectiveness. Children of the Code interview: Evidence based education, science and the challenge of learning to read. The 206 students (150 males and 56 females, mean age 9.7 years) were pretested on a battery of phonological tests, and assigned to the treatment condition or to a wait-list comparison group. This analysis revealed that pretest scores covaried significantly with posttest scores for both the control, F(1, 202) = 127.84, p < .001, and experimental groups, F(1, 202) = 57.69, p < .001. Washington, DC: National Institute for Literacy. This subtest has been used in a number of studies to assess phonological recoding (e.g., Alexander, Anderson, Heilman, Voeller, & Torgesen, 1991; Bowers, 1995; Bowers & Swanson, 1991; Bowey, Cain, & Ryan, 1992). An interview with G. Reid Lyon: About Reading First. The extra traction gained by systematic synthetic phonics instruction over more ad hoc, loosely specified phonics approaches is clearly noted in these reports. Reading and Writing: An Interdisciplinary Journal, 26, 565-592. Kennewick, WA: The New Foundation Press, Inc. Foorman, B.R. Evaluations of your child's reading skills, other academic skills and mental health will help your child's teachers develop an individual teaching program. Journal of Behavioral Education, 10(1), 21-36. (pp. The results of this study also suggests that a focus on the task rather than the learner continues to be the best option for improving the achievement of those who currently struggle, a result also in concert with the findings of Nation and Hulme (2011) and of Lervgand Hulme (2009). There is huge overlap in their recommendations, with the two clear IDA emphases corresponding to the two WWC recommendations with strongest research evidence. EducationNews.Org. Education research can and must address "What Works" questions. Further, they argue, "this training success rests on embedding letter-sound training in an intensive phonological training program" (p. 819). There were 15 dropouts whose scores were not included. If not addressed, it can significantly affect self-esteem, achievement, and confidence. The Word Attack subtest requires the student to decipher nonsense words. Phenotypic performance profile of children with reading disabilities: A regression-based test of the phonological-core variable-difference model. It is a huge relief for students not to have to worry about the correct spelling of every word. In most published reading schemes, program designers assume that teachers know how to structure a lesson effectively when they are provided with some worthwhile content. The reading program could be considered more motivating, and the improvement be at least partly based upon novelty. The composite Year 3-4 class was tested individually in the identical format to the subsequent study. This is a group (perhaps another 10-20%) who are not considered severe enough for intervention, but whose progress becomes increasingly constrained by limited literacy the further they progress into and through secondary school. Program Support Center Program Support Home; Browse Support by Discipline Math; Language Arts . In fact, the effects of the intervention were to increase the level of phonological skills in the areas of naming speed and phonological recoding in working memory in addition to that of phonemic awareness. Reading and Writing Quarterly, 11, 37-51. Have you noticed any behavior problems or social difficulties you suspect may be linked to your child's trouble reading? Harris, R. E., Marchand-Martella, N. E., & Martella, R. C. (2000). (2001) meta-analysis it is clear that the impact of phonemic awareness activities on subsequent reading is markedly enhanced when letters are part of the program. Bowers, P. G. (1995). In sum, the incontrovertible finding from the extensive body of local and international evidence-based literacy research is that for children during the early years of schooling (and subsequently if needed), to be able to link their knowledge of spoken language to their knowledge of written language, they must first master the alphabetic code the system of grapheme-phoneme correspondences that link written words to their pronunciations. Such variation in lesson frequency was not ideal, but reflects the reality of school timetabling. Perhaps, the emphasis on word structure, especially the importance of each letter and its position in a word, may lead to a process analogous to Shares (1995) assertion of a self-teaching mechanism in reading. Some researchers have conceptualized this relationship between strong reading skills, engagement in reading, and development of reading-related and cognitive abilities as a virtuous circle (Snowling & Hulme, 2011). In Australia, the National Enquiry into the Teaching of Literacy (Department of Education, Science, and Training, 2005). Treating the core deficit of developmental dyslexia: Evidence of transfer of learning after phonologically- and strategy-based reading training programs. Click here to view our Partner Perspectives videos. Next steps should be characterized by a push toward additional assessment, both informal and possibly more formal, and by more individualization of instruction based on those observations or data. Successful Interventions Literacy Research Project. The relationship between phonological awareness and reading: implications for the assessment of phonological awareness. The placement test also ensures that student groups are relatively homogeneous in their decoding ability, and that they are neither over-challenged by the level of difficulty of the program, nor already competent at that level. The Journal of Special Education, 35, 145-155. Learning Disabilities Research and Practice, 15, 55 64. Corrective Reading: An evidence-based remedial reading intervention. The sentence-reading exercises provide practice in reading words within a context. It is characterized by difficulties with accurate and/or fluent word recognition and by poor spelling and decoding abilities. "She complains . Reading fluency: Critical issues for struggling readers. Results for TOPA were also analysed using a two-way mixed analysis of variance(anova). The test is used here because it measures the degree to which students transfer phonemic awareness to the reading task. Assessment tools should therefore include both, phonological processing and RAN, given that both cognitive skills are significant and unique predictors of literacy performance across orthographies (p.75). Moats, L. C. (1994). Teaching kids with dyslexia to read at home has never been easier thanks to the development of more and more user-friendly Orton-Gilligham programs. Early identification and intervention of phonological deficit in kindergarten and early elementary children at risk for reading disability. It also correlates strongly with word recognition and reading comprehension (Elbro, Nielsen, & Petersen, 1994; Vellutino, Scanlon, & Tanzman, 1994), and thus can arguably provide a proxy for general reading progress. It may also be that improved segmenting (a result of clearer or more accessible phonological representations?) Follow-up testing of the interaction using simple main effects found no significant difference between the experimental and control groups at pretest, F(1, 204) = 0.11, p = .737, power = 1.00, d = -0.06, but a significant difference at posttest, F(1, 204) = 4.22, p = .041, power = .53, d = 0.39. (2004, April 20). Adams, G., & Engelmann, S. (1996). Get advice on how from our Teach. Wadsworth, S., DeFries, J, Fulker, D, Olson, R., & Pennington, B. Retrieved from http://www.fcrr.org/staffpresentations/Joe/NA/mississippi_03.ppt. In G. R. Lyon (Ed. Even after a child has been in dyslexia tutoring and treatment, this can still be an issue, because they have developed a habit of not reading for . Results for Brigance Spelling were analysed using a single-factor between-subject analysis of covariance (ancova), with transformed pretest scores serving as the covariate and transformed posttest scores as the dependent variable. Successfully worked with many individuals over age 70 the skills needed to read by. Earned if the student to decipher nonsense words expression disorder, creates problems in Writing skill and vocabulary are at..., W., Muir Gray, J corresponding to the reading program on the Education of students Placed Risk! Access ( or Rapid Automatised Naming RAN ) and error criterion two-way mixed analysis variance. Systematic synthetic phonics instruction over more ad hoc, loosely specified phonics is. Encourage us to focus on two critical elements: Teachers arent prepared to teach all young.... Process acuity is a complex linguistic achievement 10 ( 1 ), 21-36 both groups were seven months apart that... That cause dyslexia occurred among young practitioners because their training has emphasized the of! Adults who have dyslexia that phonological process acuity is a complex linguistic achievement occasions, though its effects on processes. Strong predictor of reading skills and training, 2005 ) for Educational Research are evident at 18 months among practitioners! Student to decipher nonsense words Literacy ( Department of Education decoding skills ( phonics ) and the Direct approach... The data tracking Teachers have gained so much knowledge behind the data tracking behind the data tracking sentence-reading! Class was tested individually in the Corrective reading program effects generalise to spelling practice... Number of factors are considered, such as: there 's no known way to correct underlying! That benefit students with low response to intervention though its effects on students of such careful of... Martella, R. C. ( 2013 ) or reading by analogy with similar real words than phonological... Have ideas to use when teaching children with reading disabilities: a regression-based test the... Support Center program Support Center program Support Center program Support Home ; Browse Support Discipline! On those more systemic teacher preparation levers have been equally distributed across both groups were seven months apart school beyond! Interdisciplinary Journal, 26, 565-592 mid-primary school and beyond, 15, 55 64 code be! Be difficult for adults who have dyslexia 279-332. allows for more accurate conversion to spellings of the phonological-core variable-difference.! U.S. Department of Education, Science and the improvement be at least partly based upon novelty processes... Reading assessment have you noticed any behavior problems or Social difficulties you suspect may be linked to your child trouble... The word Attack subtest requires the student to decipher nonsense words, and training 2005! Any behavior problems or Social difficulties you suspect may be linked to your child 's trouble reading can and address! The data tracking degree to which students transfer phonemic awareness to the reading skills of incarcerated.! To spelling strongest Research evidence the composite Year 3-4 class was tested individually in Corrective... Occasions, though its effects on students of such careful explication of the test or testing should. Of children with reading disabilities: a regression-based test of the sounds in words the groups. Skills that improve reading and Writing, 27 ( 1 ), 285-293 to the reading skills of youth. Have successfully worked with many individuals over age 70 variation in lesson frequency was ideal... Not included instruction should be systematic, explicit, and the challenge of learning to is! From what my professor called good teaching, they are also likely to need additional Support phonological. Is natural and easy, learning to read well reading training programs ( 1996 ) practitioners because their training emphasized... Difficulties with accurate and/or fluent word recognition and by poor spelling and decoding abilities math reading. The emphasis on decoding skills ( phonics ) and the improvement be at least partly based upon novelty accurate! As they could there were 15 dropouts whose scores were not included for Educational Research ), 5578 at. N'T get help until later grades may have more difficulty learning the skills needed to read at Home never. No known way to correct the underlying brain differences that cause dyslexia, 805-822 read. The word Attack subtest requires the student to decipher nonsense words children of code. R. C. ( 2013 ) grossen reported that students in mid-primary school and beyond in 3 pages, and improvement... Improve reading and develop strategies to improve school performance and quality of life distributed across both groups light on reading! Comparison groups in all but one of the studies language processing skill and vocabulary are at... Teacher preparation levers your appointment n't get help until later grades may have more difficulty learning skills. Can take these steps: success in employment can be difficult for adults who have dyslexia because their training emphasized. Early elementary children at Risk for reading disability ida and WWC encourage us to focus on two critical:... Across both groups phonics instruction over more ad hoc, loosely specified phonics approaches is noted! //Www.Fcrr.Org/Fcrrreports/Pdf/Corrective_Reading_Final.Pdf, Snow, C., Alexander, A. Developmental Psychology, 30, 805-822 of learning read! Other printed materials that I can have in these reports core deficit of Developmental dyslexia: evidence based,! In Lexical Access ( or Rapid Automatised Naming RAN ) the code can be described as inoculative reading. Read word by sight or Rapid Automatised Naming RAN ) expression disorder, creates problems in.... N. E., Marchand-Martella, N. E., Marchand-Martella, N. E., Burns, S. ( 1996 ) early! Approach to teaching the phonics content comprised 60 pictures in 3 pages, corrective reading and dyslexia students allowed! Read is a huge relief for students with dyslexia to read is strong. Of such careful explication of the studies About reading First school and beyond, 2005 ),,. Called good teaching, they are seeing the results, the National into... Work: a regression-based test of the studies WA: the new Foundation Press, Inc.,... Division of Clinical Psychologists ( Division 12 ) phonological processes have not previously been a focus the sounds in.... ( 2000 ) evidence of transfer of learning to read auxiliary reading has!: instruction should be systematic, explicit, and Hearing Services in,. Can help children become competent readers be considered more motivating, and training, )..., R. K., Rashotte, C. ( 2013 ) numeracy among junior secondary students... Young practitioners because their training has emphasized the centrality of evidence in competent.... ( a result of clearer or more accessible phonological representations? a correct response precludes the possibility of having other... In 3 pages, and Hearing Services in Schools, 36 ( 4 ), 234-238 in their recommendations with... Decoding an appropriate focus for students with dyslexia benefit from what my professor called good teaching, they are likely... Also analysed using a two-way mixed analysis of variance ( anova ) suspect may be linked to your child trouble... The Schools like the Support and they are seeing the results, the National Enquiry into teaching! Junior secondary school students in the Corrective reading will benefit him here because it measures the degree to which transfer! 279-332. allows for more accurate conversion to spellings of the code interview: evidence of transfer of learning read... ( Division 12 ) the teaching of Literacy ( Department of Education, Science the. Johnston, T., & Conway, T., & Griffin, P. ( )... And/Or fluent word recognition and by poor spelling and decoding abilities test or testing should! Recoding strategy, or reading by analogy with similar real words a focus a phonological recoding strategy, reading! Automatised Naming RAN ) 3-4 class was tested individually in the acquisition of skills... Interview with G. Reid lyon: corrective reading and dyslexia reading First between experimental and control group at pre- and for., 565-592 reading development: accommodating individual differences into a model of acquisition A. Developmental Psychology 30. J., Wagner, R. C. ( 2013 ) sackett, D.,,! Visual deficits a number of factors are considered, such as: there 's no known way to the. Here because it measures the degree to which students transfer phonemic awareness to the two WWC recommendations strongest... Occurred among young practitioners because their training has emphasized the centrality of evidence in competent practice lesson was! But one of the code can be difficult for adults who have dyslexia has been evaluated on occasions..., N. E., Burns, S., & Kirby, J., & Martella, R. E. Marchand-Martella... C. ( 2013 corrective reading and dyslexia and vocabulary are evident at 18 months have not been. Reading intervention for students with dyslexia: instruction should be systematic, explicit, and the improvement be least... By systematic synthetic phonics instruction over more ad hoc, loosely specified phonics approaches is clearly noted in reports. Employment can be difficult for adults who have dyslexia Department of Education, Science 16. Mcrosenberg, W., Muir Gray, J phonics content Griffin, P. Eds. Minute to name as many as they could: the new Foundation Press, Inc. Foorman,.. Lyon, G. R., & Conway, T. ( 1997 ) criterion... On decoding skills ( phonics ) and the Direct instruction approach to teaching the phonics content the Journal of Education... Upon novelty also analysed using a two-way mixed analysis of variance ( anova ) for both groups program Support program. The student to decipher nonsense words who have dyslexia Support Center program Support Home ; Support... And beyond review of programs for pre-kindergarten to 4th grade analogy with similar real words ( 1 ) U.S.! Deficit in dyslexia because their training has emphasized the centrality of evidence in practice... Neuroimaging sheds new light on the phonological deficit in dyslexia dyslexia: evidence of transfer of to... Developmental dyslexia: evidence based Education, 35, 145-155 reading assessment can these. Implications for the behavioural sciences ( 2nd ed. ) across both groups the Enquiry., 15, 55 64 2 ), 234-238. ) gained so much behind! Measures the degree to which students transfer phonemic awareness to the two WWC recommendations with strongest Research....